Foolproof & Super-Easy Cheese Souffle


I’m a firm believer that if you want to learn something, find a pro and ask them to teach you. Of course, you’ve got to find a nice pro who’s willing to share.

For eight years now, I wanted to learn how to make a savory breakfast-y cheese soufflé, but never really found the right person to ask. I was seeking something easy, fool-proof and a method that didn’t deal with delicately folding egg whites.

It’s breakfast, it shouldn’t be complicated and I certainly don’t do “delicate” anything early in the mornings. After all these years, I finally found my Cheese Souffle pro in Mount Dora.

We took a family trip to the very charming historic village last month and stayed at the quaint Tremain Street Cottages owned by friends Brian and Rachelle:


Oh, before I go on, don’t be fooled the town’s name, as there isn’t really a mountain at all. The town is 184 feet above sea level, and in flat Florida’s record books, that counts as a mountain.

Brian introduced us to Jim, innkeeper of the Mount Dora Historic Inn who invited us over for breakfast and cooking lesson. Eureka! Jim is a gourmet chef and lavishes his inn guests with homemade breakfast every morning.


The best part about his method is that there’s no stiff peaks, no delicate folding and Jim’s method only uses one mixing bowl. And it works, I witnessed the quick making of and the rise of the savory Three Cheese Soufflé.


How to Make Cheese Souffle

Really, only one mixing bowl. All of it comes together so quickly and effortlessly! This foolproof method only works for savory cheese souffle – not the chocolately sweet souffle.

Basically, shredded cheese goes into the bottom of the souffle dish, eggs are cracked into a mixing bowl, beaten. Then spices are added to the mixture and beaten one more time. Pour that egg mixture into the souffle dish and bake!



After 55-60 minutes in the oven at 350F….this is what comes out:


Guys, I doubt you can find an easier method of making cheese souffle…totally easy.



Three-Cheese Soufflé Recipe

Servings: Makes 1 souffle (serves 4) Prep Time: 15 minutes Cook Time: 55 minutes

Recipe by Jim Tuttle of Mount Dora Historic Inn


7 large eggs
4 ounces sour cream
1/3 cup whole milk
freshly ground black pepper
1 teaspoon dry mustard
¼ teaspoon ground nutmeg
¼ teaspoon Tabasco (or other hot sauce)
1 tablespoon butter, softened
1 ounce grated cheddar cheese
1 ounce grated muenster cheese
1 ounce grated gruyere cheeseequipment needed: one medium soufflé dish (holds approximately 22 ounces, for Williams Sonoma brand, it's the #4 size)


Pre-heat your oven to 350F.

Using an electric blender, blend together the eggs, sour cream and milk for 30 seconds. Blend in the black pepper, dry mustard, nutmeg and Tabasco.

Brush the butter all over the inside of the soufflé dish. Layer the cheese in the soufflé dish, then pour the egg mixture gently over the top. Leaving 1-inch of space at the top to prevent spillage as you carry it to the oven.

Place the soufflé dish in the oven, then carefully pour the remaining egg mixture to fill to the tippy top of the dish.

Bake for 55 to 60 minutes—the soufflé will be golden brown, puffy like a balloon, and will have risen up to three inches above the ramekin.

Present immediately to guests, as this dish will begin to fall in about 45 seconds. (if the soufflé does not fall, then the second law of thermal dynamics, does not exist in your home—if this occurs, call NASA right away)



Mount Dora, Florida

If you’re in Florida, I highly recommend taking a visit to Mount Dora, we stayed for the weekend and just had one of the best mini-vacations ever.

family photo mount dora

Quiet, quaint and small-town. The downtown area is packed with fantastic eats – including some of the best sushi I’ve had in Florida at Mount Dora Sushi

Uni Shot with Quail Egg, Ponzu Sauce and Sriracha Chili Sauce:


Crusty, fresh pizzas at Pizza Amore


A dog-lovin’ town…we happened to crash the “Yappy Hour” in downtown (yes, they really do have a Yappy Hour!)


But most importantly, good karma. Rock on, Buddha…rock on.


More information on Mount Dora at What To Do In Mount Dora.

Comments 70

  1. Shibu

    Hi Jaden,

    One of my nephews asked me to make a soufflé. As he firmly believes that I am the best cook ever, I had to try to find a flop proof recipe. You have provided me with one. Thank you. Can I add cooked or raw bacon bits? Can I use just Cheddar and Gouda?



    1. Post

      You can add anything you want! Keep the bacon small pieces (cook first, chop finely) and use whatever cheese you would like

  2. Leo Mattern

    I am the weekend breakfast cook at home and wanted to try something new for just the two of us. I used 4 eggs and used two pyrex glass bowls. It turned out to great satisfaction. Didn’t even collapse much after 45 seconds 😉 This is a great recipe and also a great plug for Mount Dora!

    1. Post
  3. Rose Marie mattern

    Hey there Earl , Interesting last name, don’t you think? My last name is the same as yours. There’s awhole family of us here in South eastern Michigan

    Rose Marie (Mattern) Zulewski

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *